edhe's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Robby The Robber Ep. I]

Nice

Quite funny, the music was good for the movie and you did a good job on the drawings.

[Madness: Pseudo (Parody)]

For a madness parody/tribute...

...this is definitely better than some of the crap that gets submitted onto NG almost every day.

Unlike some madness tributes, the violence was quite funny, the characters actually looked like the originals and the sound was suitable for the movie. The ending was especially funny.
At least you didn't compromise violence for style.

As far as i'm concerned, its quite close in quality to Krinkels' Madness - but as they say the original is the best.

KoRRupt responds:

Ofoucrse.. original is always best :) Tributes just pay tribute to the author.. because Krinkels is the man! Thanks for watching and reviewing!

[Max Payne Episode 1]

Good idea, but...

I had high hopes for this movie, during the first few seconds. A few seconds later (20 actually), it was over.

It was a good idea, but the sound was poorly optimised - 2.4mb is too big a file for what this movie was.

The little animation the movie had wasn't very good either, comprising mainly of simple object tweening. So if you do make another one, either add some more animation on the characters, or just stick with the graphic novel style.

And add some dramatic voiceacting aswell.

TypeAliasHere responds:

i no its crap but is was my first flash
but i cant update it cos i reboted my computer and forgot to make a back file

[Bargain Hunt - The Anthem]

Pretty funny...

...considering it's based on something as mundane as Bargain Hunt.

The high point was probably the song, the graphics were OK, and it did make me laugh, but on a predominantly American website, it won't get the recognition it deserves.

[CoscoUK.Ltd]

Quite boring...

...If it wasn't for the SOAD music (if i'm not mistaken) I would have probably dozed off 15 seconds into the movie. The Graphics weren't bad, nice to see the 3d effect of the greetings card, but otherwise, it was like some personal torture for me.

Needless to say, In my opinion the song doesn't really fit the theme, although the graphics just about made up for it. Not much to say on humour though...

Wonderer responds:

I know the song doesn't fit because you DIDN'T READ THE DESCRIPTION.

[The Toon With No Name!]

I Can't say it didn't deserve turd of the week...

...although it had the bare foundations of a funny cartoon (eg. "Damn them all").

If you added more animation, maybe some sounds and a better story, you could be on to something.

underscore responds:

thanx i see what ur saying, i'm gonna completly remake it soon and make it all about a bunch of characters that have been blamed, that should make it funny

[60Secs: Arnold Governator]

So good, I almost shed a tear.

I haven't seen something as stylish or as funny as this movie since 'Chipmunks Gangsta Rap'. The stills (with the blur) were especially stylish. Top marks for graphics too.

[bonjour]

Not bad...

Unlike some people, I'm not going to judge this movie badly, because it features a swinging dick or a Frenchman.
Anyone who thinks this is gay, needs their head examined.

The Graphics were quite basic, compared to some of your other works, and the sound was a bit difficult to hear, but I did find it funny - when I could understand what was being said.

I didn't find this one quite as funny as some of your other animations, especially 'Scampi' and 'Badger (ver 1)', although I do enjoy reading the negative and sometimes threatening reviews for this movie.