I made the mistake of watching this movie after a mild headache... I didn't listen to Viciousness' review (September 15, 2003), because I thought I could handle it...
As for the movie, although it didn't appeal to me, I thought it was a good first attempt.
The funniest of the two...
After having seen the second one, I think that this one is funnier, although the 2nd was a lot more accomplished - the animation in this was basically skewing and scale tweening.
But it still cracks me up every time.
It was ok...
A bit boring, and there was too much reverb in the music, but it was ok.
Funny & original...
If this was the flash you were working up to (having made the other lightsaber ones), I was impressed with what you did, and it is my favourite of your animations.
It's a step up from the other ones you've done.
I especially liked the animation of the stick figure.
You could have added more detail on the stick figure (at least add a face like on the preloader)
Wow! What an effect...
can't wait to see how you use it in the animation.
Better than the first of your movies
The preloader made me want to kill, but I thought the overall quality of this flash was quite impressive.
I think this could make a decent series...
I think that a series like this has potential. I thought that the debut episode was quite good, although the paedophilia worries me - It might be best to cut that bit out...
I like the style of your drawings to, so good luck to the series.
Are you allowed to use those trademarks?
10 for sound and graphics (because I'm a fan of the series)
But you can't just use other people's trademarks, whether or not you acknowledge them.
How can this rated 2.26 (7/27/03)
This flash movie isn't good enough to get an average of 2.26/5.00, and like someone says in an earlier review - it shouldn't have lasted 30 minutes, let alone make it into the Top 20 portal.
I had to give points for graphics (the frog had 4 legs), but I will still attempt to blam it
but it isn't the worst movie I have seen...
I liked the graphics and sound...
This movie is well made - I liked the style of graphics.
I didn't even mind the fact that it is based on the death of Maurice Gibb, because if done properly, it can't be that sick, and I know that you don't hate the Bee Gees (having read a reply to a review).
So why did I give this movie a 4 for style and a 4 for Humor? - When you make the joke that Robin is gay - but they're brothers. That's Incest. We don't do that in England!
As my overall score suggests, however, I think that the movie isn't bad, I especially like the graphics (although they're not perfect).
I can't wait to read your response - don't let me down.
Okay, the long awaited response to your review is finally here.
First of all, you had said “don’t let me down” in your last review.
I don’t like being spoken to that way, it's not acceptable. “Please don’t let me down” would have worked much, much better.
If you liked the humor but had a problem with the incest (incest in england? How veddy shocking! My word! The veddy thought! Besides, the Beegees are Aussies, not English) you should have given the humor a higher mark and let your distaste for the incest be reflected in the OVERALL score. The graphics, as you say: “aren’t bad but are not perfect.”
I agree 100%.
I tried to bang this out as quickly as I could after Maurice “bit the big one”, so that it would be as current and relevant as possible. So, you're right there. I do deserve brownie points for doing this in 5 hours.
So there you have it.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have to go fuck my sister.
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.